Wynn Resorts’ controversial venue has drawn consistent criticism from local communities who fear the flashy project will do more harm than good
The proposed $12 billion casino and resort project by Wynn Resorts and Related Companies at Hudson Yards continues to spark heated debate in New York City. While the developers claim the venue will bring substantial economic opportunities, small business owners remain apprehensive, fearing that the massive casino will impact their livelihoods and dramatically change the character of Manhattan’s West Side.
Visitors Will Have Little Incentive to Leave the Resort
For decades, small neighborhood businesses have been the backbone of Chelsea and Hell’s Kitchen, creating a diverse and rich commercial landscape. However, business owners fear that the proposed new casino, set to occupy a three-block stretch from West 30th to West 33rd Street, will irreparably change the neighborhood in ways that favor corporate interests over local entrepreneurs.
One of the most significant concerns among small business owners is the casino’s business model, designed to retain customers within the resort system where they do not benefit surrounding establishments. Speaking for local news outlet AMNY, Hudson Yards small business owners Fathy Rady and Robert Sanfiz argued that few casino guests would explore the surrounding community.
Instead of browsing our shops and dining in our restaurants, visitors will be funneled into the casino’s offerings, siphoning away crucial business.
Fathy Rady and Robert Sanfiz
The original 2009 zoning plan for the Western Rail Yards envisioned a balanced development strategy with commercial and residential spaces, including up to 5,700 housing units. However, revised casino plans dramatically alter that vision by reducing residential development to 1,500 apartments while prioritizing an expansive casino and resort complex.
Community Leaders Are Also Apprehensive
The proposed Hudson Yards casino has drawn the ire of more than just small business owners. Community Board 4 voted unanimously against the zoning change required for the project to proceed, and Manhattan Borough President Mark Levine has also voiced strong reservations. The proposal now faces scrutiny from the City Planning Commission, City Council, and ultimately, Mayor Eric Adams.
Despite relative indifference by local authorities, small business owners and community activists aim to band together and make their voices heard. They are calling for public hearings, social media campaigns, and direct lobbying to city officials to reject the proposal in its current form and push for an updated vision that will better reflect the needs of local communities.
We must demonstrate to our city leaders that this plan will hurt, not help, our community. Let’s work together to ensure that development benefits everyone, not just the developers.
Fathy Rady and Robert Sanfiz
As the battle surrounding the proposed Hudson Yards casino unfolds, the fate of local businesses and the character of Chelsea and Hell’s Kitchen are on the line. With 11 New York casino proposals and only three downstate licenses up for grabs, Wynn Resorts and Related Companies could face an uphill battle if they disregard community feedback.
